More than once in your life you have heard the famous saying that you must teach by example. You've been lied to. Teaching by example does NOT work.
But what are you saying...?
Let's be more precise so we don't create a mistaken controversy. What I really mean is that teaching by example is NOT enough to get the results you need from your team.
For instance, if you want your employees to arrive on time, or rather, to fulfill their working hours without being late, it barely helps if the boss arrives early. You are putting your company's culture at risk if you let punctuality depend on the boss arriving early. The reason your employees usually arrive on time is a) because you made clear from day one what working hours they must keep (surely it's even in a written contract), b) you follow up, checking whether they arrive early or NOT and giving them feedback, and c) there is a reward or punishment, usually monetary (a deduction for lateness).
It has surely happened to you more than once that, no matter how many times you have seen something done, it's not until it's your turn to do it that you realize all the details you did NOT pay attention to.
I remember that when I was learning to sell, I attended many sales meetings and thought I was ready, but the moment I had to make my first sale, many doubts came to mind that never occurred to me during all the times I was just watching. What should I say to start the conversation? What should I ask to learn more about their needs? What do I say to close, and so on and so forth?
Something similar happened to me as a kid, when I was taken to secondary school. No matter how many hundreds of times I walked the same route, the day I had to go on my own, that is, when I was no longer driven and had to decide which direction to take at each step, I did NOT remember exactly how to get there. That's because I never truly paid attention. After the first day and getting lost for a while, I never forgot the route again.
Recently, with the help of a coach, I realized a mistake I was making when managing people. Sometimes, unexpectedly, I drop into the meetings my different teams hold, and when I notice that something in our management process is not being done right, or our culture is breaking down somewhere, I step in. I do NOT let it slide. For example:
- María, before you stop sharing your screen, why do those tasks in the follow-up stage still have no planning date?
This same attitude of actively protecting our work methodology and our culture, and correcting on the spot every time a breach is detected, is what I expect from each of our team leaders, and in general from every employee. But whenever I rejoined a meeting, I found that the leader was not doing it the way I expected. BUT I am setting the example, and they see me do it every time.
Until one day, our newly hired head of Talent Management, whom we brought onto our team and who, thanks to her experience, has helped me improve my management by acting in part as a talent management coach for me, said to me after a meeting:
- Those interventions you always make should be made by the team leaders.
- Yes, I answer, that's what I expect, but apparently, no matter how often they see me do it, they don't learn.
- That's not it, she says. The problem is that they don't understand they should follow that example. To them, your interventions seem to be made in your role as CEO or manager, and they don't realize they wouldn't need to make them, that they are the ones who should apply those corrections.
She was right. From then on, every time I have to step in during a meeting to address a topic I expect the leader to address, I now tell them explicitly:
- Jorge, I tell him, what I just showed María, I need you to teach your team and correct them every time you see it is NOT being followed.
In this way, setting an example is not enough, and taking for granted that what they must do is understood. Instead, I make it explicit in clear instructions, but even so it is not enough. What else must be done? Many more things:
- Making sure they have understood me, by asking them: What is going to happen the next time it is NOT done?
- Following up with the leader to make sure they comply. This involves a periodic review of the leader, evaluating their behavior and adding a measure of their team's compliance.
- Reward or punishment. In our case, we set a performance indicator that measures their team's compliance on certain key aspects of our work methodology, which determine leaders' growth within the company.
But this doesn't stop here. Following this same advice, there's something else we want our leaders to learn and carry out. They need to understand that when I explicitly tell them what I expect from them and make sure they understand it, they must apply the same with their team.
DON'T misread the message. I'm not saying that setting an example is useless. What I'm saying is that it's not enough, and when managing talent in a highly competitive private company environment, we cannot leave important things to chance. Setting an example is also important, but on its own, it is insufficient.
Don't assume anything, don't take anything for granted. Make it explicit and make sure they understand you by asking questions.